33 Of The Most Amazing Elmo Cakes You Will Love

Elmo is an adorable character that is beloved by young and old. See our list of amazing Elmo cake ideas for your next celebration.

A Few Words About Elmo Cake

There’s nothing like an Elmo cake to liven up your party. Elmo is one of the most beloved characters in Sesame Street, with his cute voice and playful side. That’s why it’s also a popular character among kids and adults, so we’ve decided to create this list filled with some of the most amazing ideas for Elmo Cakes to get you inspired.

Some of these cakes are impressive three-dimensional ones. These cakes are so life-like, making it seems like Elmo is sitting at your table. But we understand that you might be looking for a simpler cake, so we’ve included several quick and easy ones for all beginner bakers out there.

Come and look, then tell us which is your favorite Elmo cake!

1

Two-Tier First Birthday Elmo Cake

Is your little one’s first birthday coming up? Then you will enjoy this inspiration for Elmo first birthday cake design.

This is a cake with fondant and print-out decorations. Although the cake looks neat and impressive, it’s not difficult to create. Start with the chocolate-flavored base cake, then layer them to create two different tiers. Then cover them with fondant.

The decorations are very easy to make, the balloons and circles can be formed and cut using a carving knife, and the Elmo cake topper is made of a sugar sheet printout. This is a very beginner-friendly cake that anyone can make.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

2

Cookie Monster and Elmo Cake

Here’s another wonderful idea for an Elmo Sesame Street cake. This Elmo cake features Elmo’s head and a Cookie Monster cake topper. The cake is only a one-tier cake, so you can create it using any base cake you prefer.

Then she started by showing that she covered the entire cake with some red buttercream frosting. You’ll need to refrigerate the cake overnight first so that the cake takes its form. Then place a fur mold onto the cake to create Elmo’s fur.

If you don’t have this, you can get creative and use a scoring knife instead. Then create the “one” lettering using fondant – the o is a cookie, and the m and e are made to look like Cookie Monster! Overall, a very fun cake that your kids will love.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

3

Elmo Birthday Cake

This is another Elmo cake idea that looks impressive but takes little effort to make. This Elmo cake is adorned with Elmo’s favorite food – candies! The maker showed you a shortcut using store-bought cake as the base cake.

Then she layered them using store-bought buttercream. The cake’s shape is unique. It’s tall and rectangular with divots to emulate a shopping bag. So be careful when you stack them together. Then cover it with some white fondant for a clean finish.

She then painted Elmo right onto the shopping bag with edible paint. If you want something easier, you can always print out Elmo and stick it onto the bag. Lastly, stick several of your favorite candies on top of the cake.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

4

Elmo cake Idea for Beginners

Here’s one of the best Elmo cake ideas because it’s very impressive but still beginner-friendly. It’s also a nice cake for those of you who are not big fans of fondants. This Elmo cake is entirely decorated with buttercream instead.

She started with a single-tier vanilla sponge cake, layering them with some vanilla buttercream. You can customize the cake using your favorite flavors instead. If you think Elmo’s eyes and nose are made with fondant, you’re wrong!

They’re made with cake crumbs that are mixed with some chocolate! Then pipe on Elmo’s fur using a piping bag.

Total preparation time: 5 hours 30 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

5

Elmo Cake with A Rainbow Cake Surprise Inside

Here’s a creative Elmo cake design for those who like a surprise. This cake is an Elmo cake with a rainbow cake surprise inside! The rainbow surprise is made by stacking six layers of cake of different rainbow colors as your base cake.

Then stack them with some vanilla buttercream and cool them in the fridge so that the shape stays. It’s important to chill it first because the height is quite unstable.

Then start covering the entire cake with vanilla buttercream before finishing it with some fondant decorations. The maker used an Elmo stencil, but you can definitely print out Elmo’s face and use that instead.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

6

Easy Elmo Cake

Here’s another fun Elmo face cake design. It’s also very easy to make for all beginner bakers out there. You start by leveling some vanilla sponge cakes layered with red vanilla buttercream.

Then you chill the cake so that the shape will be more stable. Then start preparing the red buttercream for your piping bag. You’ll be making Elmo’s cake using the piping bag, so you might want to practice on a piece of paper first.

Keep piping until you cover the entire cake. Then create Elmo’s eyes and nose using some fondant. A very easy cake that will delight all your guests.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

7

Simple Elmo Cake

If you think the previous Elmo face cake is easy, this one is even easier! This Elmo face cake is also simply made by stacking two layers of vanilla sponge cake and covering them with some red buttercream icing.

The maker showed us that they used a piping tip that’s made to look like a hair or grass tip. Then cover the entire cake with the red buttercream frosting by piping it on.

Lastly, they used Elmo cake topped to create Elmo’s eyes, nose, and mouth. But if you don’t want to spare for the cake toppers, you can just print out Elmo’s eyes, nose, and mouth and stick them on instead!

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

8

Elmo Birthday Smash Cake

Here is a cool idea for Elmo’s birthday theme. Elmo birthday cake with some matching Elmo smash cakes! The centerpiece is made using a delicious chocolate sponge cake as base cake, then covered in red buttercream icing.

Then the accompanying twin smash cake is also made with some cute, smaller chocolate cakes. They’re both also covered in some red buttercream. Then start piping Elmo’s fur onto the cakes.

Lastly, create Elmo’s features using some decorative fondants. Don’t forget that you’ll need to create a triplicate because you’ve got three cakes. Elmo would approve of these triplets!

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

9

Fondant Elmo Cake

Here’s a very fun Elmo cake for your creative little ones. This Elmo cake is a single-tier cake that features numbers, Elmo, and some crayons on top of the cake. Something that your kids can relate to.

The base cake can be made using your favorite flavors. Make sure it has a considerable height to fit Elmo’s half-body. Then start creating the decorative elements using fondant.

The crayons are made using fondant and then painted with edible paints. She also made Elmo’s body using a red fondant by stenciling a printout. Overall, a very manageable cake to make, but it still looks impressive.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

10

Elmo Cake Design

This very cute Elmo cake features all of Sesame Street’s colors. The cake is a single-tier cake, with a waving Elmo on top and sides that are decorated with sesame street colors – blue, orange, green, red, and yellow.

First, she created Elmo’s body by chilling some fondant in the fridge. Then she created the lettering using Sesame Street’s format – you can customize it by having the birthday boy or girl’s name and their age!

Then start piping on the sides to look like pom poms using some colorful buttercream, and your colorful Elmo theme cake is ready!

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

11

Elmo Cake with Sesame Street Cupcakes

This is a wonderful Elmo cake cupcake that you can create to delight any Sesame Street fan. The centerpiece will be Elmo’s face or an Elmo smash cake. Then the accompanying cupcakes will be Sesame street themed, featuring lots of Elmo’s friends.

This way, everyone can have their favorite characters. The base cake and cupcakes are made using chocolate sponge cake. Then the Elmo cake is stacked with some cookies and cream buttercream before being covered entirely using red buttercream.

Then start decorating with piping bags to create the fur. You’ll create Elmo, Cookie Monster, regular cookies, and cream frosting for the cupcakes.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

12

Fondant Cookie Monster & Elmo Cake

Here is another classic Elmo cake featuring wonderful colors. This cake has beautiful colorful stripes, balloons, and the iconic Sesame Street marquee lettering that spells the birthday boy or girl’s name and age.

It also has Elmo and Cookie Monster toppers to make things more festive. Start with stacking several vanilla sponge cakes with vanilla buttercream, then cover the single-tier cake with the buttercream before decorating it.

Then you’ll create several decorative elements using different colored fondants. The good news is you’ll be using printouts for Elmo and Cookie Monster toppers. Making this cake is very easy to make.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

13

3D Elmo Cake

Are you up for a challenge? Then this very cute three-dimensional Elmo cake is for you. This cake features Elmo sitting in front of another cake with the number one on it. So, it’s a perfect cake for your little one’s first birthday.

The cake will require a lot of preparation and materials, so make sure you have enough time to create this. The maker will show you exactly what you need and how to create each element, making this a long tutorial.

This cake is filled with challenges, from stacking the cake to create the right shape, covering it in buttercream and red fur, and finally putting the tiny cakes in front of him. But the result is a very impressive cake you’ll be proud to present to your guests.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

14

Elmo Cake Idea

This two-tier Elmo cake features colorful decorations and Elmo’s face. Start the cake with your favorite base cake flavors, then stack them to create the two tiers you need. Then cover the bottom cake with yellow buttercream and the top tier with white buttercream.

This will give you the Sesame Street color scheme, making it recognizable to everyone. The good news is that the decorative elements are made using printouts only. So you’ll print out Elmo’s face, several balloons, and lettering to stick onto the cake.

Overall a pretty simple cake that’s still presentable. It’s also a great alternative for those who dislike fondant since it’s made entirely of buttercream and printouts!

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

15

3D Sitting Elmo Cake

Here’s another challenging cake for those who want to expand their cake-decorating skills. This cake is a beautiful three-dimensional sitting Elmo cake, and you’ll be carving, shaping, and creating all day long!

Make sure you have enough time to create this cake. You’ll probably need around a day for trial and error. Start with stacking your cake and covering them with some crumb coat, then start decorating with red buttercream to create Elmo’s coat.

After that, you’ll create several details using different colored fondants, from the mouth and nose to his eyes. It’s a challenging cake, but you’ll be pleased with the result.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

16

Easy 2D Elmo Cake

Looking for an easy Elmo cake to make? Or are you making the cake last minute? Then this easy Elmo cake is the perfect answer for you. This is another cake that features Elmo’s face. A two-dimensional cake that is simple but still fits the theme.

Start with your vanilla sponge cake and buttercream to create the base cake. You can customize this using your favorite flavors and choose chocolate or strawberry.

Then use fondant to put on the decorative elements – Elmo’s mouth, nose, and eyes. Then you’ll finish by using red buttercream piping to create Elmo’s fur coating.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

17

Simple 3D Elmo Cake

This is another fun and quick Elmo cake to make. Although you might think it’s the same as the other two-dimensional Elmo face cake, this one had a three-dimensional element to it.

They put Elmo’s mouth to the side of the cake instead of the top, and the other face elements are put on top. The elements on top are also created in a three-dimensional format.

Instead of having a flat face, the eyes and nose are created to emulate spheres. Before covering the entire cake with some red buttercream with grass piping, create the elements first. A fun and easy cake to make that will still delight your guests.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

18

Beginner Cookie Monster & Elmo Cake

Here’s a wonderful cake that will impress your guests. It’s a two-tier cake that features Cookie Monster on the bottom and Elmo on top. The base cake is made from chocolate sponge cakes and layered with vanilla buttercream frosting.

The only challenge you’ll face while making this cake will be when you stack the tier and piping on Elmo’s and Cookie Monster’s furs. Then you’ll finish with some features you’ll be making with fondant – their eyes, noses, and mouths.

It has a similar technique to other cakes on this list but presents a difference by having two tiers instead of one.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

19

3D Elmo Cake & Cupcakes

This is a festive idea for your Sesame Street-themed party. Not only will the tutorial show you how to create an Elmo three-dimensional cake, but it will also show you how to make Elmo cupcakes and cake pops.

You’ll start with making the base cake and styrofoam, shaping them into a sitting Elmo. This will be challenging, and you’ll need several structural supports. The maker decided to create the Elmo shape using styrofoam, as they’re much lighter and easier to deal with than actual cake.

Then you’ll create the cake details using fondant and Rice Krispies. Overall, it’s an easy cake to make, and the tutorial teaches you several tips that can be useful.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

20

Smash Elmo Cake

This cute little Elmo cake is meant to be a smash cake. A smash cake is a small cake that’s made for a baby’s first birthday. They’re supposed to have fun with it, smash it, and smoosh it if they want. And that’s exactly what this tiny cake will be.

That’s why the maker kept the decorative elements simple and edible. Since every single thing on the cake should be safe for the baby to eat. She started by stacking layers of vanilla sponge cakes with buttercream icing.

Then she covers it with red buttercream icing to create Elmo’s fur and lastly puts some fondant eyes and nose for Elmo’s features.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

21

Elmo Cake with Simple Design

This detailed recipe shows you how to create the base cake, from sponge cakes to decorating them. Overall, the cake is very simple. You don’t even need to stack too many layers; the height is less than 10 cm.

Then you’ll cover it with some crumb coat before covering the cake with red buttercream piping. Line out a space to put Elmo’s mouth, and spread some cocoa powder or cookie crumbs to make the mouth.

Then create Elmo’s eyes and nose using fondant, and finish off by putting them on Elmo’s face. A super simple recipe that you can whip up at the last minute.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

22

Elmo Cake Idea

This short tutorial shows you how to create a very simple Elmo cake. It’s a really helpful one when you’re short on time.

You start with your regular vanilla sponge cakes that you’ll stack until a considerable height with vanilla buttercream. The real challenge will be when you cover the entire cake with some red buttercream icing by piping them one by one.

Make sure you have a steady hand when you do this, or even start by practicing on a paper before you move on to the actual cake. Then finish off with fondant decorative elements for Elmo’s eyes and nose.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

23

Simple Buttercream Elmo Cake

Here’s a cuter cake on the simple two-dimensional Elmo face cake. The cake has a bit of a divot to create Elmo’s mouth. You start with some regular vanilla sponge cakes as your base, but this can be customized with whatever you prefer.

Then cover the cake with crumb cake before working on some of the designs on the cake. Then line out Elmo’s mouth to the side of the cake. The tutorial will show you where it should go.

And start layering the cake with some red buttercream icing to create Elmo’s fur. Then finish with black buttercream icing and different colored buttercream icing for his eyes and nose.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

24

Cute Smash Elmo Cake

Here’s another simple and cute Elmo smash cake. This cake can be made at the last minute, is not very detailed, and is super easy.

That’s because it’s intended to be a smash cake, so you’re supposed to have fun with it and let your kids haphazardly smoosh it when they want to. Start with some simple vanilla sponge cakes, then stack them with vanilla buttercream. Cover the cake with some red buttercream icing.

Don’t forget to create a divot on the side of the cake to make a spot for his mouth. First, fill that up with some black icing, then continue with your red buttercream fur icing.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

25

Easy Elmo Cake

Are you tired of the two-dimensional Elmo cakes we have? Then you’ll be delighted with this breath of fresh air. This Elmo face cake is three-dimensional, so you’ll impress your guests with this cake as a centerpiece.

This cake differs from the rest because it’s made with fondant instead of buttercream. You’ll also shape the head to a spherical shape instead of the flat cylindrical shape the rest of the cakes have.

Then cover it in red fondant entirely, and carve out Elmo’s hair using a stick or a carving knife. Overall, it’s a very simple cake with an impressive three-dimensional look.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

26

Elmo Cake with Fondant Topper

This is another simple two-dimensional Elmo face cake. The difference is that this one is decorated using Rice Krispies and fondant instead of buttercream icing. You start with a chocolate sponge cake and vanilla buttercream icing as your crumb coat.

But this can be customized using your favorite flavors. Then cut a bit of a divot on the bottom of the cake to create a more realistic head.

Make sure you pile on a considerable amount of icing for your crumb coat because you want the cake to be smooth without any air bubbles to prepare for your fondant covering.

After covering it with fondant, pinch it using scissors to create a fur-like texture. Lastly, create Elmo’s mouth using black icing.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

27

Red Velvet Elmo Cake

Are you a fan of Elmo and red velvet? Then this cake is the perfect recipe for you because it combines red velvet as the base cake and Elmo-themed decorations.

In this recipe, not only will you make your red velvet cake, but you’ll also be making your buttercream icing. But if you’re looking for a shortcut, you can always buy buttercream icing from cake shops and then color them at home according to the color theme.

Not only will you be using this buttercream icing for Elmo’s fur, but you’ll also use it for Elmo’s eyes, mouth, and nose. So make sure you have enough.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

28

Simple Elmo Cake with Edible Paint

This is another simple Elmo face cake. But the good news is that this one will show you some easy shortcuts to make the process much easier. The tutorial uses a box cake mix to create the base cake, a chocolate sponge cake.

This can easily be customized using your favorite flavors. Just make sure they have variety in the shops. Then start carving out Elmo’s face using a knife. The tutorial does not want to use the whole cake; rather, she cuts out several parts to be much more accurate.

Then start decorating the cake using colored buttercream. You’ll need several different piping bags because the cake requires at least four colors.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

29

Creamy Elmo Cake

Here’s another cool Elmo face cake. The difference is that this cake also features some Sesame Street color theme on its sides. The cake is called the Creamy Elmo cake since most of the decorations are made using buttercream icing.

Start with your base cake; the maker used chocolate sponge cake, which can easily be customized according to your taste. Then layer them to create considerable height before you cover them entirely with red buttercream icing.

Start piping with a fur tip to create Elmo’s red coat. Then, you’re done by using another piping bag to pipe on Elmo’s face features. Truly a simple cake that will still delight your little ones.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

30

Quick and Easy Elmo Cake

This is another easy DIY Elmo cake decoration. The base cake is vanilla sponge cake. This cake is so simple that the maker decided not to layer the cake. Instead, use the leveled-out cake directly and coat it with crumb coating.

Then cover it with some red buttercream icing piping bag. Meanwhile, prepare the fondant decorations by shaping them to emulate Elmo’s features. We recommend you chill the cake during this time since buttercream icing can easily melt if you’re not careful.

When you’re done with the decorative elements, take out the cake and start building up Elmo’s features.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

31

Elmo Cake & Jumbo Cupcake

Here’s a fun cake if you’re interested in showcasing interesting centerpieces during your party. This tutorial will show you how to create an Elmo cake, and the maker will also show you how to create a cake that’s shaped like a jumbo cupcake.

You start with the base cake first, which is separated into two different layers – the first layer will be the “cup,” and the top layer will be the “cake” part. The base layer will be covered in brown buttercream to create a cup-like shape.

Then the top layer will be covered in red buttercream icing to create Elmo’s face. Don’t forget to finish using fondant to create Elmo’s facial features, and you’re done!

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

32

Refreshing Smash Elmo Cake

Here’s another rendition of a baby’s smash Elmo cake. Like other smash cakes, you’ll start using a smaller base cake. The maker decided to use vanilla sponge cakes and vanilla buttercream icing, but you can definitely use your favorite flavors instead.

Cut out Elmo’s face and facial features using fondant, then place it on top of the cake. Lastly, decorate the cake using some colorful fondants in a circular shape.

You’ll also need to create a Sesame Street marquee that you can use to display the birthday boy or girl’s name and age. A beautiful cake that has a different color scheme than the others, it’s a refreshing take on Elmo smash cake.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

33

Last Minute Elmo Cake

Do you only have an hour left for your Elmo-themed party? Then this last-minute Elmo cake is the perfect option for you to try. Start with vanilla sponge cake and layer it with red-dyed vanilla buttercream.

You can also customize this cake and use other flavors if you’d like. After you’re done with the crumb coat, evenly cover the cake with the red buttercream and start creating the fondant decorations.

Start with putting on the mouth first, then pipe on Elmo’s fur one by one. After you have Elmo’s fur, put Elmo’s eyes and nose on top, and you’re done with your simple, last-minute Elmo cake!

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe