32 Best Pistachio Pudding Ideas You Would Love To Make

Would you like to freshen up your day with some pistachio pudding? Try one of our recipes and see how easy it is to make this dessert.

A Few Words About Pistachio Pudding

Have you ever tried pistachio pudding? Pistachio pudding is a green-colored pudding made from pistachios that occasionally has pieces of chopped almonds in it. The pudding became popular when Kraft Foods developed an instant version in 1975; getting this delicious and simple dessert everywhere is so easy.

This list will give you five categories: original pistachio pudding recipes, pistachio pudding salad recipes, pistachio pudding cookies recipes, pistachio pudding pie recipes, and pistachio pudding dessert recipes. From the simple Watergate salad to a no-bake pie, we have everything you need to have fun with pistachio pudding. Dig in and let us know which one is your favorite!

See the best selection of Pistachio Pudding Recipes

Want to try the original recipe? Then try one of these recipes for pistachio pudding, and find out why there’s so much hype for this delicious dessert!

1

Pistachio Pudding with Almond Extract

Pistachio and almond go so well together; that’s why it’s common to see almonds being in a recipe for pistachio pudding. We mentioned a boxed mix that you can readily use to create pistachio pudding; this tutorial will show you how to make it from scratch.

After reading this, the maker guaranteed you’d want to throw away the boxed mix. To make this dish, you’ll need raw pistachios, milk, sugar, butter, egg yolks, cornstarch, and almond extract to take the flavor to the next level.

Serve it alone or with a dollop of whipped cream on top of the pudding. The result will be one of your family’s favorite desserts!

Total preparation time: 35 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

2

Easy Homemade Pistachio Pudding Shot

This is another homemade pistachio pudding that you can make from scratch. But the catch is it’s also an easy recipe. The maker promised that this is one recipe you’ll want to use when you’re short on time but need something to fill the dessert slot.

The difference between this recipe and the last one is that this one uses pistachio paste and vanilla instead of almond extract for extra flavor. So if you prefer your pudding to have the original pistachio taste without interference from other nut flavors, this can be your recipe.

Another highlight of this recipe is how they cleverly serve this pudding inside a shot glass. Everyone can have their servings in one shot.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

3

Homemade Pistachio Pudding Parfait

This tutorial will give you new knowledge to learn a little about pistachio’s history and facts. They mentioned they were unsatisfied with boxed pistachio pudding, so they tried to create their recipe from scratch.

Similar to the first recipe, they use a little bit of almond extract to elevate the taste of this pudding. But the difference is they make this pudding into a parfait. A parfait is a layered dessert that involves different ingredients in each layer.

For this one, they used crushed shortbread cookies interlaced with the pudding. Another surprising ingredient in this recipe is cream cheese, giving it a more prosperous and creamier texture.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

4

Keto Pistachio Pudding

Are you on a diet and looking for a healthier alternative for desserts? Then it would help if you tried this fantastic sugar-free pistachio pudding recipe. This is a keto-friendly, sugar-free, and dairy-free pudding.

Who says that delicious desserts can’t be healthy? The maker even promised that this recipe could help curb sugar cravings if you’re on a keto diet. How does this dairy-free dessert get its creaminess?

Well, it turns out that the maker swapped the dairy products with some coconut cream. The coconut cream is blended with pistachios, vanilla extract, and stevia. If you have other preferences for sweeteners, you can swap stevia with anything you’d like.

Calories per Serving: 178
Total preparation time: 5 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

5

Pistachio Pudding From Scratch

This is another healthier alternative if you would like to make pistachio pudding. This one is an egg-free pudding recipe. This recipe is impressive because it uses only five ingredients to make the dessert, so you won’t have to buy too many products that you won’t use in the future.

The ingredients are milk, pistachios, cornstarch, sugar, and vanilla extract. All you need to do with this recipe is soak the nuts, blend everything before chilling it, and serve it to your family.

You can also make this a healthier version by swapping the sugar for sweetener and making a sugar-free recipe, but it’s all up to you.

Calories per Serving: 256
Total preparation time: 40 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

6

Homemade Pistachio Pudding

Here’s a different take on the pistachio pudding recipes that adds another layer to the flavor. Not only does this recipe show you how to make it from scratch, but it also shows you how to infuse more flavors into the pudding.

Like any other recipe, you will soak the nuts overnight before using them. Then this is where it gets interesting; this recipe will tell you to use the leftover water. They call it pistachio milk, which adds more flavor to your pudding.

That’s why this recipe does not include any other flavorings, such as almond or vanilla extract, and it presents the pistachio flavor in its proper, natural form. If you’re curious, try it out and let us know how it goes!

Calories per Serving: 330
Total preparation time: 2 days 20 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

7

Sugar-Free Pistachio Pudding

This recipe is for people who hate washing and spending too much time in the kitchen. Unlike the other recipes on this list, this recipe uses a boxed pudding mix!

We’ve included this one in this recipe group because it uses a different type of boxed pudding – the sugar-free one! This is a great treat if you’re looking for a quick snack that won’t ruin your diet. The recipe is sugar-free and low-calorie, but you won’t miss any of the flavors.

Another plus point is that it only needs skim milk and sugar-free pudding mix! We recommend you add one more element to the mix, though, crushed pistachios!

Calories per Serving: 70
Total preparation time: 5 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

See the best selection of Pistachio Pudding Salad Recipes

You may have heard of a Watergate Salad, a delicious fruit salad with pistachio pudding as its main ingredient. On this list, we will give you some variations that you can make.

1

Pistachio Pudding Salad with Coconut and Pecans

Let’s start the list with a beautiful rendition of the original Watergate Salad. First, we’ll explain why this pistachio pudding salad is known as the Watergate Salad. If you didn’t know what Watergate was, it was a scandal in the American government.

And this pistachio pudding fruit salad is called that because there are so many nuts in it – like the nuts inside the scandal. Some people said this salad has so many cover-ups, so they might call it that.

Nevertheless, this is a simple recipe with merely four ingredients: pistachio instant pudding, coconut flakes, pecans, and cherries. Another good addition to this tutorial is they give you an ingredient swap list if you have specific dietary requirements or preferences.

Calories per Serving: 116
Total preparation time: 1 hour 15 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

2

Simple Pistachio Pudding Salad

This very traditional recipe will give you a peek into the maker’s family tradition. It is said that they have been making this dish forever whenever Easter comes around the corner. So you can bet that his recipe will taste amazing as it has been through the test of time.

There’s a difference with the last recipe; this one is a pistachio pudding salad with pineapple. You will only need three ingredients to make this pistachio salad: a mixture of pistachio pudding, crushed pineapples, and whipped topping.

It’s a simple dish that you can throw together in mere minutes. Although it does need a couple of hours of refrigeration, you should consider that before you make this last minute.

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

3

Jello Pistachio Pudding Salad

With just a glance at the picture, you’re going to realize that there’s a difference between this recipe and the last – marshmallows! Here’s a great recipe you can make if you have little ones coming to your party.

With just a single look at the mini marshmallows, they’ll be begging to get a serving. This recipe is quite similar to the previous one; the two additional ingredients you will need are chopped pecans and mini marshmallows.

Otherwise, it’s the same recipe but with a twist. This recipe also only requires several minutes to put together, but you must chill this before serving it to your family and friends.

Calories per Serving: 86
Total preparation time: 8 hours 15 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

4

Watergate Pistachio Pudding Salad Recipe

Here’s another Watergate Salad recipe that you’ll love. This one will combine everything on this list, from the mini marshmallows, chopped pecans, pistachio pudding mix, crushed pineapples, and whipped topping.

This adds a little topper that sweetly closes the dessert – a maraschino cherry on top. If you want to try a recipe that combines everything great about Watergate Salad, this one should be the one you attempt.

Serve this inside shot glasses or a more oversized serving glass, as shown in this tutorial. Another significant aspect of this tutorial is they provide a video, so you can choose how to follow it.

Calories per Serving: 241
Total preparation time: 10 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

See the best selection of Pistachio Pudding Cookies Recipes

Believe it or not, you can make delicious cookies with instant pistachio pudding! With some creativity and technique, we will show you how to do it in these recipes.

1

Chocolate Chip Pistachio Pudding Cookies

Who knew that pistachio pudding mix could be used to make cookies? That’s right; it turns out that this instant mix can aid you in making more accessible cookies by using it as a base.

It’s a great addition when you’re celebrating St. Patrick’s Day, and it’s also so simple to make. You will need butter, pistachio pudding mix, eggs, vanilla, all-purpose flour, and semi-sweet chocolate chips to make this recipe.

You will treat the pudding mix as another dry ingredient; consider it a part of the flour. You should also use clear vanilla extract if you want your cookies to be as green as possible because regular ones may give you a brownish batter. 

Calories per Serving: 84
Total preparation time: 20 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

2

Cranberry Pistachio Pudding Cookies

Do you want to inject fiber and antioxidants into your pistachio pudding cookies? Then it would help if you tried this recipe made by the Domestic Rebel. These cookies with cranberries are chewy, soft, and buttery; you won’t be able to stop at just one.

What’s great is that you’ll also eat some fruit with your cookies, thanks to the cranberries, which means less guilt for those trying to be healthier. The recipe is a little more complicated than the last, as you will need additional ingredients.

But the taste is in another class; you should try this if you have time. For example, they also use a little bit of brown sugar to add to the caramelization and chewiness of the cookies.

Total preparation time: 15 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

3

Macadamia Pistachio Pudding Cookies

We’ve been showing other nuts to pair with pistachios, from pecans to almonds. Now we will give you an alternative that will expand your culinary taste. Pistachio cookies with macadamia nuts!

We know these native Australian nuts may be a bit too expensive or rare for you, but the taste is something you should try occasionally. Macadamia nuts have a slightly buttery flavor, which pairs well with pistachio’s crunchy and clean taste.

The ingredients are similar to the last recipe, but instead of cranberries, you will swap them with chopped macadamia and white chocolate chips. The result is one of the best cookie batches you’ll ever taste. Try it, and thank us later!

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

4

Gluten-Free Pistachio Pudding Cookies

Are you suffering from gluten intolerance? Or are you lactose intolerant instead? Then this recipe for pistachio cookies that are gluten-free and dairy-free is the perfect addition to your recipe book!

This tutorial by Mama Knows Gluten Free has a taste similar to pistachio ice cream, so if that’s something right up your alley, you should try this recipe. Looking at the list of ingredients, you can be a little intimidated because we admit it’s quite a long list!

But think of these as healthier cookies you can make in a large batch and keep inside your pantry. Then every time you’re craving something sweet, you can turn to this healthier cookie instead of junk food!

Calories per Serving: 79
Total preparation time: 20 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

5

Crinkle Pistachio Pudding Cookies

Don’t you hate it when your cookie is smooth with no crinkles? It will miss that chewiness and crispness you can only get with crinkles. That’s an issue with ingredients, especially how much butter you mix in and the temperature you’re baking your cookies.

This fail-proof recipe lets you enjoy your pistachio pudding cookies with crinkles every time you bake.

The secret ingredient to this recipe is sour cream or Greek yogurt, which will contain the moisture of your cookies until it’s ready to be released and create the crinkle you need when you bake them inside the oven.

Read up or watch the video on this recipe page to find out how to mix in this secret ingredient and create your crinkle cookies! 

Total preparation time: 22 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

6

Pistachio Pudding Cookies with White Chocolate Chips

If we’ve been giving you nut-pairing alternatives, this one will take you by surprise. Instead of the usual nut pairings, we’ll give you white chocolate instead! The recipe calls for similar ingredients: brown sugar, flour, pistachio pudding mix, eggs, butter, flour, baking powder, vanilla extract, pistachios, and white chocolate chips.

All you need to do is mix everything to create the cookie dough. Then when you’re done, you can chill it for several hours.

This will help you to make even dough distribution and avoid spreading it too much before you bake it. The technique will also lead to better-looking cookies with uniform sizes.

Calories per Serving: 106
Total preparation time: 22 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

7

Original Pistachio Pudding Cookies

If you’re tired of the alternatives to pistachio pudding cookies, we have given you; then this original recipe might be a better alternative for you to try. That’s right; we’re giving you plain pistachio cookies without all the other fancy additions.

The recipe calls for regular cookie dough ingredients with pistachio pudding mix and chopped pistachio nuts. The result is a chewy, delicious cookie that gives you precisely the taste of all-natural pistachios.

They also allow you to add some green food coloring if you’d like the dough to have a slightly greener color. But you won’t need it since the pudding mix has green colors. 

Calories per Serving: 115
Total preparation time: 20 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

See the best selection of Pistachio Pudding Pie Recipes

Aside from salads and cookies, you can make a chilled pie with pistachio pudding. All you need is a crust, and you’re good to go!

1

Pistachio Pudding Pie with 5 Variations

What else is pistachio pudding mix well for? Believe it or not, you can make an easy pie that requires simple ingredients. You’ll love this recipe that requires little to no effort.

Another fantastic thing about this tutorial is that they give you four different variations of the pie, which means you can read up and decide which one is more suitable for your preference.

The first variation is the original without any additional ingredients, the second one is a variety that includes chocolate, the third is with coconut, and the last one is with pineapple. 

Calories per Serving: 295
Total preparation time: 2 hours 10 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

2

Easy no bake Pistachio Pudding Pie

If you’re a beginner baker looking for the easiest pie recipe, this tutorial is one you should try.

The recipe is the original version of the pie, and the ingredients are pistachio pudding mix, graham cracker crust, milk, cream cheese, butter, powdered sugar, and whipped topping. You can add fanciness to the pie by topping it off with crushed pistachios, maraschino cherries, or whipped cream.

All you need to do is mix all the ingredients, let it chill, and set it inside the refrigerator. Then you will top it off with the garnish after it’s properly developed.

Calories per Serving: 283
Total preparation time: 2 hours 5 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

3

Pistachio Pudding Pie with Chocolate Drizzle and Oreo Crust

If you’ve got some little ones in your home, you should try this recipe for a pistachio pudding pie. This is a pudding pie with Oreo crust and chocolate drizzle on top, which creates an impressively beautiful serving for each slice.

You will need a pistachio pudding mix, milk, cream cheese, heavy whipping cream, sugar, crushed pistachios, and Oreo pie crust to make this dish. You can buy the Oreo pie crust straight from the shop, or if there’s none available near you.

You can make your own by crushing some Oreo cookies and mixing a little bit of butter. Another additional flavor can be infused into the pie if you’d like by adding the Oreo filling to the pie!

Total preparation time: 2 hours 15 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

4

Pistachio Pudding Dessert Bites

Don’t you love bite-size appetizers? These amazing pudding pies are bite-size appetizers that will make a great addition to your party favors. Another great thing about this recipe is that it only requires five ingredients!

So if you’re a lazy cook or need more time, this recipe is perfect. The ingredients are phyllo dough shell, cool whip, pistachio nuts, milk, and pistachio pudding mix. Mix the ingredients, then bake the shells.

When the shells are cooled, pour the batter into the shells and chill for several hours. Top each shell with maraschino cherries, and your lovely party favor is done.

Calories per Serving: 37
Total preparation time: 10 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

5

Pistachio Pudding Pie in a Jar

This is another cute individual serving recipe that you’ll love. You can serve this as a party favor during St. Patrick’s Day or when you have parties at home. But be mindful that you’ll need at least a dozen jars if you’d like to make this recipe.

If you don’t have a pot, you can replace it with serving glasses. These pie jars have three layers: the first crust, the pistachio pudding layer, and the whipped topping. Make them layer by layer by creating the crust using crushed pretzels.

Then you’ll top that off with pistachio pudding and the whipped cream topping. You have to wait until each layer is set before adding more on top, so this might take some patience.

Total preparation time: 35 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

6

Frozen Pistachio Pudding Pie

If you like your pies to be delicious and rich, this wonderful frozen pistachio pudding pie can be the perfect recipe. Why does it need to be frozen? Well, because this recipe also includes ice cream in its list of ingredients!

That’s right; we’re betting your kids jump for joy when you serve this delicious pie. To make this recipe, you will need crushed graham crackers, butter, instant pistachio pudding, crushed pistachios, fat-free vanilla ice cream, and fat-free chocolate fudge.

If you’re not a fan of fat-free ice cream, you can swap that with regular ice cream or frozen yogurt. Remember that their taste will be different. Traditional ice cream will give you more creaminess, while frozen yogurt will provide you with tartness. So, choose wisely!

Calories per Serving: 261

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

See the best selection of Pistachio Pudding Dessert Recipes

Because there are so many inspiring recipes, we include everything in this pistachio pudding dessert list. We’ve got layered cake, trifle, and bars you can take anywhere. Dig in and try a few of them!

1

Pistachio Pudding Icebox Cake

We’re starting this list strong with a pistachio pudding icebox cake recipe. This easy dessert recipe has layers of creamy goodness with graham crackers, pistachio pudding, and whipped cream.

First, you need to prepare the bottom layer of the crust using graham crackers and butter; then, you’ll schedule some of the pudding mixes for the second layer. While you let those two chills, prepare the third layer of cream cheese.

You will spread the cream cheese between two layers, so you’ll have a cream cheese sandwich! Top the cake off with some crushed pistachios and cut them into squares.

Calories per Serving: 281
Total preparation time: 2 hours 20 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

2

Layered Pistachio Pudding Dessert

The following recipe is another showstopper that will impress your guests. This nifty little dessert has layers of green, yellow, and white that will delight your guests. It will feel like you’re holidaying at a tropical getaway with these dessert slices.

The ingredients you need for this recipe are instant pistachio pudding mix, vanilla pudding mix, sugar, cool whip, flour, butter, chopped pecans, cream cheese, and cold milk. The yellow layer comes from the vanilla pudding mix.

This recipe will need you to let each layer cool and set before you pour another layer on top, so you will need to be more patient when making this recipe.

Total preparation time: 30 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

3

3 Ingredients Pistachio Pudding Dessert

This unique recipe is similar to the Watergate Salad but can be treated more as a layered dessert. A good thing about this recipe is that you will only need three different ingredients: pistachio pudding mix, crushed pineapple, and whipped cream.

All you need to do is to mix all the ingredients, then let them chill for several hours in the fridge. After that, pour them into individual serving glasses and top them off with maraschino cherries.

You can swap the cherries with something else, such as strawberries or blueberries. Another good addition would be crushed pistachios.

Calories per Serving: 100
Total preparation time: 1 hour 5 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

4

Pistachio Pudding Dessert Bars

If you’d like a recipe that’s easy to share, you’ll love this pistachio pudding dessert bar. The concept is similar; you will layer several ingredients and cut them into bars or squares for your guests to enjoy.

The list of ingredients in this recipe is long, but we guarantee it will be worth the effort. We want to make a straightforward recommendation for you to make enough for several outings and keep it for easy access.

It’s the perfect addition for your outdoor picnic or for more appetizers to serve to your guests. If saving it for later use, you should put the whipped cream on later.  

Total preparation time: 1 hour 5 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

5

Easy One Pan Pistachio Pudding Dessert

Here’s another wonderful pistachio pudding dessert recipe that you can try at home. This particular recipe is called Pistachio Lush, and it is quite similar to the layered desserts we have on this list. The maker decided to create five different layers into this dessert.

The first layer is the graham cracker layer which will be the base of the cake. Then you will add on the pistachio pudding layer, cream cheese layer, and another pistachio pudding layer.

Lastly, you’ll use chocolate syrup and cracked pistachios on top of the cake. Try to create a pattern with the chocolate syrup by using a fork or knife to give it a beautiful visual.

Calories per Serving: 160
Total preparation time: 2 hours 55 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

6

Pistachio Pudding Trifle Dessert

If you haven’t heard of trifles, this is the perfect time to try making one yourself. This recipe is a simple dessert that you can make at home. You will need an angel food cake mix, instant pistachio pudding mix, milk, cream, sugar, and vanilla extract.

Like the other dessert recipes in this list, you must create layers to make the trifle. First is the angel cake, then the green pudding, then the whipped cream layer.

Keep going until you reach the top of the bowl. Remember to use a clear bowl so that everyone can see the beautiful layers and admire your hard work. Top the trifle with maraschino cherries and crushed nuts.

Calories per Serving: 337
Total preparation time: 1 hour 20 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

7

Pistachio Pudding Bread

If you want something that can last longer than other pudding dessert recipes, you should try this recipe for pistachio pudding bread! That’s right, aside from cookies and pies, you can also make bread.

You need flour, eggs, butter, salt, baking powder, sugar, milk, and a pistachio pudding mix. Oddly, you don’t need yeast to make this bread, but in our defense, this is a flatbread, so it doesn’t need any.

Mix everything, then bake the bread. An optional step for this recipe is to wait for the bread to cool, then add some icing sugar, milk, and pistachio nuts to create a prettier-looking bread.

Total preparation time: 1 hour

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe

8

St Patricks Day Pistachio Pudding Dessert

This is another beautiful recipe for pudding dessert that you can make to impress your guests when you’re having a potluck. This dessert is also an excellent addition if you’re thinking of celebrating St. Patrick’s Day.

You will need to make this recipe: pistachio pudding mix, butter, pecans, flour, icing sugar, vanilla, cream cheese, white chocolate, whipping cream, and milk. To create a beautiful visual, you will layer the cream cheese and pudding interchangeably.

Another good part of this recipe is that they will give you some options to swap ingredients. For example, if you want to make gluten-free dessert or if you want to swap out the toppings. 

Calories per Serving: 312
Total preparation time: 30 minutes

Click here to see the instructions for the Recipe